What Would Wayne Dyer Do? Apparently, being a jerk is something he’d do.

A couple of days ago in a post about freedom, I quoted Wayne Dyer. His words made me think about my own children’s freedom, about the freedom I ask for myself, and the freedom I allow other people and things to take away from me.

I read the rest of his book, Pull Your Own Strings, and I found myself becoming less and less enchanted with Wayne Dyer’s idea of freedom. In the name of freedom, apparently, it’s perfectly OK, and even encouraged, to be a jerk.

You see, I learned from this book that there are people everywhere who want to victimize me. And little did I know that people are sneaky about it. And although he didn’t say it outright, women are the worst about it! Because women talk about things, and want to understand each other and get to know people. That’s apparently a trick to get people to be weak. Don’t let people do that to you, Wayne Dyer warns! They’re just trying to get you to say things about you so they can manipulate you!

At the apex of his two chapter long diatribe about how people use mind games to get at us, he proves his point by describing a parent who has learned not to be victimized. This parent asked his teen to take the trash out not once, but twice. He didn’t get mad, or beg his son to comply, or, God forbid, explain himself. He simply dumped the trash on the teen’s bed. The teen got the message that his dad couldn’t be manipulated or victimized.

What the hell?

I was livid after that example, but I calmed down and went ahead and finished the book anyway. After I put it down, and breathed a little, I reminded myself that before I reached the chapter on How to Be a Jerk How to Keep People From Manipulating You, I really liked what Wayne had to say.

He talked about how we can be trapped by our past. He described different ways of handling criticism. He talked about how we have a choice whether to be happy. He also went into how our own negative judgments of others are a voluntary way to victimize ourselves. Some of the examples he gave were spot-on and gave good tools for how we can choose to live more peacefully.

And I’ve read a couple other books by him as well, that had a lot of good to say. (I haven’t yet read “Your Erroneous Zones”.) Should I reject everything he’s said, or never read a book by him again, because of these two paranoia-inducing chapters?

No. I needed be OK with cherry picking.

Yesterday at church (OMG, Tammy goes to church! Shhh… don’t tell anyone), the speaker’s topic was about cherry picking. His cherry picking had to do with the bible. See, the church I go to doesn’t use the bible. In fact, there are some people in the congregation who really abhor the bible and anything to do with Christianity or religion at all. (There are others who are very Christian. A truly mixed group.)

Anyway, the speaker, Ross Blocher, said that even though there is a lot of violence and other passages in the bible that may not resonate with our beliefs, there is also lot of good to be found in it According to Ross, we shouldn’t reject the bible if we aren’t Christian (he isn’t Christian either), but rather to cherry pick the best parts and appreciate those parts for what they have brought us (while also having a critical mind for all of it).

Now, I might have just alienated my entire Christian audience, and I hope I haven’t. I don’t want this to be a discussion about religion. My point is that even though parts of Wayne Dyer’s attitude towards people makes me glad he’s not my friend or in my family, he does offer a lot of good ideas I can cherry pick and appreciate.

I’ve struggled with this idea because I couldn’t see how it could be done without being insincere or manipulative. I’ve been struggling with being able to appreciate people and things for the good parts in them while recognizing with equanimity that bad parts exist too. I have always felt like that if I say I “like” something, it’s a tacit approval of every single part of it. It’s either I support everything, or I support nothing. I don’t feel comfortable saying I like a speaker, a teacher, a book or a method, unless I like all of it. One wrong word, and it’s tainted everything else he or she has said or done in the past (and future).

Pretty limiting way of looking at things, isn’t it? If I keep going like this, I will never have any friends (because all people have faults), I will never be able to appreciate an author (because no writer is perfect), I will eventually run out of things to like at all (because all things eventually show “their true colors”). This idea that once someone or something has shown their “bad” side, I can no longer offer my appreciation, is just plain dumb. What’s the matter with me? Part of it is that for most of my life, I didn’t even realize I was doing it.

I think this idea of all or nothing is purpetrated in our society. A perfect example is our political attitudes. But we can also see it in how reluctant people are to accept homeschooling (or even to accept each other within the homeschooling community), or in family members who turn their backs on each other, or in people’s product loyalty (Can we say Apple vs. Microsoft?) Let’s not even get into the whole monster of “patriotism”.

I struggle with cherry picking when it comes to being a homeschooler, even. Because even though I support homeschooling, there are certain aspects to it that bother me. When some ugly part of homsechooling comes out, I start to feel that knee-jerk mental withdrawal. Almost as if I had been betrayed. In fact, a few weeks ago, I read an online discussion about homeschooling, and I was appalled by some of the comments my fellow homeschoolers made. And, to be honest, some of the non-homeschoolers in this particular discussion brought up some really astute points about the problems with homeschooling. For a while after I read the discussion, I wanted to just throw in the towel, and be done with it all. Of course, I can’t do that, because I have to pick some kind of educational process, so I continued on homeschooling.

And, on the flip side, even though I don’t send my kids to school, there are many things about school that I appreciate. If something good pops up about school, I it’s natural to push that information aside, to justify my continued negative attitude I’m “supposed” to have toward school.

It’s a long, slow process to learn to simply see. There is something to appreciate in every person. I am losing out when I push away ideas and people who have a lot of good, simply because I can’t see past the negative. I have already lost out on much because of that. I’m becoming increasingly aware of that.

In the end, I can decide to appreciate a person, a book, a theory, a perspective, a method, a political group, or even myself, without having to be what gamers call “a fan-boy”. I can cherry pick. I can’t tell you how much freedom I suddenly feel I have from this one simple idea that most people probably already “get”, but it took me a long time to finally allowed myself to accept.

Wayne taught me more by example, than by his words. By being a jerk, he taught me about how to be free.


12 Responses to “WWWDD?”

  1. Sheri Says:

    Wow…what a great post.

    I can relate. It took me a long time too, to get that you “don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater.”

    I spent many years dismissing the good in things just because there were parts that made me cringe. The Bible is a very good example of this.

    BTW, I’m a Christian and I wasn’t at all offended by your post. Quite the contrary, I think it would serve a lot of Christians well to be more discriminating about what they are taught about Jesus and to not believe everything written about Him.

    Anyway, as always, thanks for your courage in your writing Tammy, it’s very inspirational.

  2. Tana Says:

    Yeah, I am a Christian, and I think that even Christians cherry-pick what they like out of the Bible. We grab what we understand, gloss over what we don’t. Each denomination claims to have the truth, but clearly they all have different truths, so which one is it?

    Very thought-provoking post, as usual. Thank you.

  3. sunniemom Says:

    I am a great fan of cherry pickin’. Everything I do seems to be a compilation of things I have learned from a variety of people, books, situations and experiences. And I too had that epiphany more recently than I care to admit, but who cares when you get there, as long as you get there before you qualify for Social Security! 😀

  4. Anna Says:

    What kind of church let you in after taking their entrance exam 😉

    I think it is sad that WD lives in a world where no one is kind for the sake of kindness, no one is interested in your thoughts unless they are going to use them against you or that trying to really understand someone is just a ploy instead of a chance to obtain a deeper meaning.

    It is that attitude that continues to marginalize homeschoolers. People don’t TRULY listen to us about homeschooling, they simply write us off as arrogant or freaks.

  5. Melissa Says:

    Hey Tammy! Great post.

    With regard to “cherry-picking”. I have done that many times with other books of the same persuasion. It’s all like the grocery store. There are LOTS of choices. Sometimes even the same brand has several products. You might like one, you might hate the other. But, you don’t necessarily reject that one particular brand.

    Reading, homeschooling, friends…..pick the one you like, leave the rest….

    someone else will buy it. ~Melissa

  6. Penina Says:

    Enjoyed your post, Tammy. Feel like doing one about Dr. Phil next? I think the people that are helped by him should be acknowledged for finding truth and healing despite him!

    I just wanted to share a great Jewish saying. It translates out to, “I ate the fruit; the skin, I threw away”. (Tocho achalti, Klipato zarakti).

    And that’s just another way of cherry picking!

  7. jhcckkm Says:

    I was tag surfing and read this post….seriously, my friend and I were talking about this about four hours ago. A little freaky, eh 😉
    Anyway, thanks for the thought provoking post – – it was awesome!! : )

  8. Karen Says:

    Great post, as usual, Tammy! I have a long-time homeschooling friend who declared she followed the cherry-pickin’ method of homeschooling years before I had ever heard it used elsewhere. Choose what you need, discard the rest. What you discard might just be the thing for someone else!

  9. Medieval Affaire » Cherry Picking Says:

    […] was reading Tammy T’s most recent post about “cherry picking” the ideas that resonate with you from a certain philosophy and discarding the ones that […]

  10. Kimberly Says:

    I really like what you had to say in this post. How can we possibly agree with anyone about everything? In fact, I am happy we don’t.

    I really enjoy your blog. That doesn’t mean necessarily that I’ll agree with everything you say, EVER. We are different people. I respect you and your ideas. I agree with many of those ideas you have. And I appreciate that when we have different ideas, you and I will offer each other something new to consider… And your ideas don’t threaten mine if they are not the same because I am secure within myself regardless. Likewise, I don’t wish to threaten anyone with my ideas. It’s just about sharing when that is appreciated.

    We cherry-pick all throughout life. Then again, perhaps some don’t because they would like to take an easier route that is accepting everything as either black or white. It requires less mental effort. Or maybe it’s just a bad habit.

    Wonderful thoughts to consider anyway…

  11. Tammy Says:

    Thanks everyone for the great comments.

    Sheri – I’m very glad you said that you weren’t offended. I’m only just learning about the Bible and Christianity beyond the very simple “do as you’re told” version I was taught as a small child.

    Tana – That’s a very interesting perspective. You’re right! So, whose cherry picking is the right kind? Who gets to decide? I’m glad it’s not me 🙂

    sunniemom – Seems like the most prudent and mature way to go about things. And I agree with you, life isn’t a race or competition; the journey is the most important.

    Anna – I’m starting to wonder if my “church” is actually a place of religious practice, or if it’s an excuse to get together and party with food and coffee 🙂

    Melissa – That’s a perfect analogy. Thank you.

    Penina – That’s another great analogy. I’ve always been fascinated by the wisdom of Judaism (although only recently being able to honestly appreciate it). I’m glad you stopped by.

    jhcckm – What a coincidence! Small world 🙂

    Karen – It’s interesting, I’ve always been a “cherry-pickin’ homeschooler. For some reason, I didn’t extend that out to everything else. I *wanted* to… but in practice, old habits are hard to break.

    Kimberly – Good insights. It’s all about appreciating each other, even when we don’t agree.

  12. Dawn Says:

    [The other must read is WWWDD? at Just Enough, and Nothing More. Tammy deals with cherry picking in a post about liking some of what Wayne Dyer has to say, despite thinking he’s a jerk…]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: