Homeschoolers, as individuals, are just as weird as public or private school families. As individuals, we all have our quirks. It just so happens, that homeschoolers aren’t too troubled to hide those quirks, because there is a general feeling of accepting each other (while at the same time being confident in ourselves being who we are too.)
Homeschoolers are different than the rest of the population, purely because we’ve chosen an non-mainstream way to educate our kids. Instant weirdness. And, we are almost all opinionated, without much fear of how others might perceive us. Double weirdness.
Homeschooled kids are weird, just like the kids on the school yard. But instead of having that weirdness squelched out of them, homeschool kids are given less pressure to change who they are in order to conform. They are often up front about how their opinions and interests are different than others. In other words, they don’t have different opinions to prove a point. They don’t have uncommon interests in order to stand out from the crowd. These interests are genuine.
Since these kids are all coming from their own unique perspective, just as any kid is, they are just as likely as school kids to judge each other’s experiences as being “different”. The younger the kids, the more likely they are to come out and say, “you don’t do things the way I do.” I don’t have any fantacized expectations that all the homeschool kids I meet are going to be nice to my kids. I expect kids to be kids. They say things that aren’t perfect. They make judgements.
The difference between kids on the school playground making comments about my kids doing things differently, is that my kids can stand up for themselves without having to worry about being beat up or ganged up on. So what if their friends (or even very un-friends) say they don’t like something they are interested in? They can say, “Well, I don’t care what you think” and move on. In school that kind of statement is a test of “are you on my side or their side.” Homeschooling kids, even if they are living a totally different life than ours, aren’t on anyone’s side, they are on their own side.
That said, there are definitely “cliques” in our homeschooling group. Both with the adults and kids. The difference between the cliques in our HS group, and the ones in school, is that there is no exclusion based on that – people just get along with each other and tend to do the same kinds of things, so they hang out together. We’re all nice to each other tho and don’t cause trouble for one another. Same with the kids in the HS group. Although there might be differences of opinion of what is fun and good, there isn’t exclusion or shunning based on this. (I realized that not all groups are like this. Homeschoolers are still people too, and are subject to the same social pressure as everyone else. I wouldn’t belong to a group that did that, homeschooling or otherwise.)
Homeschooling’s not perfect – nothing is. But it’s better. Better than kids having to be all alone in their social battles. Better than kids having to live up to someone else’s expectations of what is cool. Better than kids having to face a 6-8 hour day of worrying about being beat up for being different.
Homeschooled kids are weird. I don’t see why that’s a problem. Doesn’t school teach kids to deal with all kinds of people in all kinds of situations? If that’s the case, what does it matter that a few homeschooled kids are weird? We all learned how to get along with each other in school, without exclusion or hating upon others, right?




November 7, 2006 at 4:45 pm
Better than kids having to face a 6-8 hour day of worrying about being beat up for being different. That is not true sure some kids face that but not all. That is like saying all hs’ed kids sit at home all day and are not social when we know many are.
November 7, 2006 at 5:26 pm
You’re right. It’s actually fairly rare that kids face being physically beat up on a daily basis. (thank goodness!)
But you have to consider other ways of being “beat up” emotionally.
And you’re also right that not all kids have this worry at the forefront of their psyche. But too many kids do. (And not to mention the kids who actually *do* worry about it, but we don’t count it because they are popular and “cool”.) In homeschooling you don’t have to.
A public school experience is not necessarily a bad thing. People can get through it unscathed, and thrive. But as a design, it is faulty, and allows for these situations where kids are helpless, many are in fear (of physical or emotional pressure) and forced to worry about things that they have no control over.
I don’t agree with how the system works. But even so, it’s not all bad. Kind of like ice cream – I like all sorts of flavors, but I like vanilla best – it’s far more versatile and goes with just about any topping.
June 18, 2007 at 8:27 am
I think my daughter said it best, “Even when school wasn’t awful, it never made me as happy as staying home and being myself does. When I was myself at school, a lot of times teachers and kids told me it was a wrong self. At home, I don’t have a wrong self. I’m just happy me.” School may be a good fit for some kids, but so far, I’ve met many more who say it wasn’t a good fit, because of the bullying (often while teachers were chit-chatting with their backs turned on the playground), boredom, testing, regimentation and mindless rote work. I consider it 11 yrs wasted out of my life, and that’s from the perspective of 45 yrs later.
Shine On,
Lill
June 18, 2007 at 4:53 pm
Fantastic post! I hated all the conformist pressure in the public schools I attended from 4th-12th grades. I had to endure a lot of ridicule from my classmates for being brainy and outspoken. I definitely don’t want that for my daughter. Better to be who she is and considered “weird” than to play dumb just to fit in.
Thanks for sharing!
June 19, 2007 at 6:49 am
[...] Tammy, of Just Enough, Nothing More, said “Homeschoolers are Weird“ I couldn’t help but giggle. I should put a banner up that reads “Weird, and proud of [...]
June 19, 2007 at 11:40 am
If everyone were weird, we’d all be normal. But why be normal? I’d have nothing to write about.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
Peace and Laughter,
Cristina
January 28, 2009 at 11:18 pm
I think the comment about parents always treating each other kindly is a wonderful way to view the world. In homeschooling communities it would be remiss of us to say that everyone gets along all the time. We still have issues with people getting their feelings hurt, kids being left out and cliques forming. With homeschooling if kids are friends then the parents are usually friends, too. Sadly, if parents have a falling out, then the kid’s friendships end, as well, and vice-versa. It is sort of sad, but a fact of homeschooling. I actually see a lot of shunning going on in the homeschool community. It can be pretty sad and devastating.
January 29, 2009 at 10:19 pm
I’m homedschooled and theres nothing wrong with that, i read this and was insutled about every word i read. Being homedschooled is bit different. But we are not weird. Its like me saying that pubicschoolers and weird and all that, but i respect them.